33
Shares
Share this post










Submit

Black and Blue Review

Black and Blue Review

Carolina Panthers News and Coverage for the Digital Age

Panthers Miss Out on Tackle Target, But Land Their Linebacker

During the 2014 draft, the Panthers felt they had a good chance to grab their left tackle of the future. But before Ja’wuan James could get to them at the 28th pick, he was snagged by the Dolphins at No. 19.Thursday night, Carolina again hoped to land a potential franchise left tackle, and again missed out. The Cardinals scooped up Florida product and Charlotte native D.J. Humphries with the 24th pick, one spot ahead of the Panthers. But it’s not like they were disappointed with their consolation prize. If Humphries was option 1A, Washington linebacker Shaq Thompson was 1B.”Bottom line is they were the two guys we were talking about. D.J. and Shaq, those were the two,” Gettleman admitted after taking Thompson with the 25th pick. “Either way we’re getting a really good football player. They’re both really talented. They both have big upside. They’re talented guys, and we would not have been disappointed either way. That’s the way it fell.”For months, mock draft after mock draft placed offensive tackles in Carolina. The entire league knows the Panthers need to groom a young guy for the left side, so it’s not like the team doesn’t. But the offseason addition of Michael Oher at least has them in a better position now than they were last year when Byron Bell became the best option.Adding the versatile Thompson does a number of things that could further improve a defense ranked in the top 10 each of the last three seasons. First, it makes it hard to argue the Panthers won’t head into 2015 with the best linebacking corps in the league. Thompson, Luke Kuechly, and Thomas Davis form a fast and intimidating trio that could spend plenty of time on the field together.

View image | gettyimages.com
While the Panthers have increased their use of a nickel defense the last few years, they often found themselves in mismatches. But now, instead of sending out a smaller nickel back, the 6-foot, 228-pound Thompson can help counter the league’s evolving offenses.”What it’ll do for us is allow us to keep three linebackers on the field when a team goes to 12 — a person on two tight ends, and one of those tight ends is a Jimmy Graham-style football player,” coach Ron Rivera explained. “You’ve got to be able to matchup with those types of guys, and when you bring a defensive back in you create different types of matchup problems, or they do for you. This gives us an opportunity if we have to match a certain situation by personnel; we can do it.””At the same time, if a team catches us with regular defensive personnel under the 4-3, we can matchup against 11 personnel, so we feel pretty good about that.”Washington used Thompson, who won the Paul Hornung Award as the most versatile player in the country, at running back, linebacker and safety last year. The junior racked up six touchdowns: Two rushing, one interception return, and three fumble returns.The flexibility is a plus for many, but a problem for others. At February’s combine, Thompson told teams he believed his NFL future was at linebacker. Not everyone could see it. The Panthers did.“I compare myself to (Bucs linebacker) Lavonte David,” Thompson said on a conference call with Carolina media from his home in Sacramento. “I feel like me and him were the same, size-wise. He was athletic, he was able to play in space. He was able to guard tight ends, running backs, and I felt like he was an athlete.”Locally, Thompson has been likened to Davis throughout the draft process. Comparing a couple guys who each played linebacker and safety in college makes sense, but Rivera was quick to remind reporters to not get too carried away just yet.”There’s a lot of characteristics that they share, but to honest with you, there’s only one Thomas Davis,” Rivera said.Ironically, it was the 2014 NFL Man of the Year who read Thompson’s name from the stage in Chicago. Davis, the first active player to announce a pick, did it for his eventual successor.The Panthers are working on extending Davis’ contract, but taking Thompson was also a part of their long-term plan. Davis is 32, and while he likely has at least a couple good years left, the end is coming eventually.”My responsibility as a general manager is to look short term and long term. I’m on a tightrope, and I’ve got to think about those things. So, everything we do is to fit both needs,” Gettleman said. “Shaq is a great scheme fit for us. He’s a talented, talented kid, and he’s got a lot of upside.”

View image | gettyimages.com
When he arrives in Carolina, Thompson won’t threaten to take Davis’ playing time. The rookie will play, but he’ll also listen and learn from two of the best linebackers in the league.”You look at the potential to have him in the mix with Luke on the field with him, and ‘TD’ with him, and again, he’s going to come in and he’s going to have to earn his opportunities. But there are some things that we can do that we feel are going to help us as a football team,” Rivera said.”There are some long-term things that you sit there and go, ‘Wow, this guy has a chance to grow. Hopefully he’ll have a long career here, and he’ll be that guy that’s going to be here a long time.”

SHARE THIS POST
Share this post










Submit
  • Panthers/Truth

    LT Jake Fisher is a much better LT prospect than Humphries. Fisher (6’6 1/8, 306, 33 3’4″ arms, and 10 3/8″ hands) is bigger than Humphries by every measure, except weighing 1 pound less. Fisher is also far more athletic than Humphries, with much better Combine results in every event, except for 1 bench rep, and this is reflected by their SPARQ (Speed, Power, Agility, Reaction, and Quickness) scores, an OT best 94.2%, to Humphries 43.2%.

    Humphries had a long injury history in college, including his last 2 seasons ending early with knee injuries, and a injry prone college player, usually becomes an injury prone pro player. All the game tape on Humphries is virtually useless, because he’s no longer the same player, after gaining around 22 pounds after the season, and that’s shown by his below average SPARQ score. Humphries is like 2 different players, one on game tape, and the other at the Combine.

    I’m very glad that the Panthers didn’t draft Humphries, and just the fact that they wanted him, makes me question their evaluations even more.

  • Panthers/Truth

    LT Jake Fisher is a much better LT prospect than Humphries. Fisher (6’6 1/8, 306, 33 3’4″ arms, and 10 3/8″ hands) is bigger than Humphries by every measure, except weighing 1 pound less. Fisher is also far more athletic than Humphries, with much better Combine results in every event, except for 1 bench rep, and this is reflected by their SPARQ (Speed, Power, Agility, Reaction, and Quickness) scores, an OT best 94.2%, to Humphries 43.2%.

    Humphries had a long injury history in college, including his last 2 seasons ending early with knee injuries, and a injry prone college player, usually becomes an injury prone pro player. All the game tape on Humphries is virtually useless, because he’s no longer the same player, after gaining around 22 pounds after the season, and that’s shown by his below average SPARQ score. Humphries is like 2 different players, one on game tape, and the other at the Combine.

    I’m very glad that the Panthers didn’t draft Humphries, and just the fact that they wanted him, makes me question their evaluations even more.

  • Panthers/Truth

    What in the world is RR thinking, Shaq Thompson can’t defend a TE like Jimmy Graham, who’s 6’7″, 265, with 35″ arms, while Thompson is only 6’0 1/8″, 228, and 33″ arms. It goes beyond just being much smaller than Graham, he also can’t jump as high (33 1/2″ to Graham’s 38 1/2″), has longer arms, and is also much slower as well (4.64-40 with a 1.72-10, to Graham’s 4.60-40 with a far better 1.53-10). Thompson will be eaten alive, if he tries to defend Graham.

    Thompson fits the mold of a 4-3 OLB, but lacks the required speed (1.72-10, in the bottom 10% for both S’s and OLB’s over the last 10 years) to be a blitzing pass rusher (only 3.5 sacks in 3 seasons). The Panthers could have waited until the 3rd or 4th round, and chosen the 3rd best athlete in the whole draft (by his fantastic 99.5% SPARQ score, to Thompson’s 47.4%) OLB conversion OLB Davis Tull, who’s much faster than Thompson (4.57-40 with a 1.52-10, to Thompson’s 4.64-40 with a 1.72-10), bigger (6’2 3/8″, 246, to Thompson’s 6’0 1/8″, 228), and an outstanding jumper (42 1/2″ vertical with an 11’0″ broad jump, to Thompson’s 33 1/2″ and 9’9″). Tull also brings a pass rush, with 32 sacks in the last 3 seasons (to Thompson’s 3 1/2 during that time), which would help restore the 20 sacks the Panthers lost from 2013 to 2014, and Tull was also the “Southern Conference Defensive Player of the Year” for each of the last 3 seasons. Tull’s pass rush ability to blitz, more than offsets Thompson pass coverage experience, because Tull has the better speed and jumping ability to eventually be good in pass coverage.

  • Panthers/Truth

    What in the world is RR thinking, Shaq Thompson can’t defend a TE like Jimmy Graham, who’s 6’7″, 265, with 35″ arms, while Thompson is only 6’0 1/8″, 228, and 33″ arms. It goes beyond just being much smaller than Graham, he also can’t jump as high (33 1/2″ to Graham’s 38 1/2″), has longer arms, and is also much slower as well (4.64-40 with a 1.72-10, to Graham’s 4.60-40 with a far better 1.53-10). Thompson will be eaten alive, if he tries to defend Graham.

    Thompson fits the mold of a 4-3 OLB, but lacks the required speed (1.72-10, in the bottom 10% for both S’s and OLB’s over the last 10 years) to be a blitzing pass rusher (only 3.5 sacks in 3 seasons). The Panthers could have waited until the 3rd or 4th round, and chosen the 3rd best athlete in the whole draft (by his fantastic 99.5% SPARQ score, to Thompson’s 47.4%) OLB conversion OLB Davis Tull, who’s much faster than Thompson (4.57-40 with a 1.52-10, to Thompson’s 4.64-40 with a 1.72-10), bigger (6’2 3/8″, 246, to Thompson’s 6’0 1/8″, 228), and an outstanding jumper (42 1/2″ vertical with an 11’0″ broad jump, to Thompson’s 33 1/2″ and 9’9″). Tull also brings a pass rush, with 32 sacks in the last 3 seasons (to Thompson’s 3 1/2 during that time), which would help restore the 20 sacks the Panthers lost from 2013 to 2014, and Tull was also the “Southern Conference Defensive Player of the Year” for each of the last 3 seasons. Tull’s pass rush ability to blitz, more than offsets Thompson pass coverage experience, because Tull has the better speed and jumping ability to eventually be good in pass coverage.

  • koda57

    I think there’s a lot of *IFs* in this draft class. If these guys turn out to fit the mix like Gman and RR say they will then Gettleman’s reputation could sky rocket but if they turn out not fitting the mix then his reputation will greatly depreciate.
    I really don’t think we can Grade this Class right now. We’ll have to wait and see how all this pans out on the field.

    If the Twin Towers can create miss matches Cam should have a much better year. If Shaq can play sideline to sideline and guard TEs then the defense should be back in the top five.
    I can’t wait until training camp and see how all these *IFs* work out.

  • koda57

    I think there’s a lot of *IFs* in this draft class. If these guys turn out to fit the mix like Gman and RR say they will then Gettleman’s reputation could sky rocket but if they turn out not fitting the mix then his reputation will greatly depreciate.
    I really don’t think we can Grade this Class right now. We’ll have to wait and see how all this pans out on the field.

    If the Twin Towers can create miss matches Cam should have a much better year. If Shaq can play sideline to sideline and guard TEs then the defense should be back in the top five.
    I can’t wait until training camp and see how all these *IFs* work out.