Vote thumbs up or thumbs down after each group’s analysis
Newton tossed touchdowns to receiver Kelvin Benjamin and tight end Greg Olsen, but there were missed opportunities in the passing game as well. On a drive that ended the third quarter and started the fourth, Benjamin had a score brought back when he was called for pushing off, and two players later, Newton overthrew Olsen in the end zone.
In overtime, receiver Jerricho Cotchery dropped what would have been a game-winning touchdown.
Starting running back Fozzy Whittaker scored the first rushing touchdown of his career, but after nine carries and 25 yards, he was held out after his troublesome quad acted up again. Undrafted rookie Darrin Reaves replaced Whittaker and gained just 15 yards on eight carries.
Jonathan Stewart, who had his sprained knee heavily wrapped, worked with strength and conditioning coach before the game and was inactive. He should have a good shot to start next week in Green Bay.
Charles Johnson picked up Carolina’s only sack, which actually doubled the Bengals’ 2014 sack total.
With start receiver A.J. Green out with a toe injury, Mohamed Sanu set career highs with 10 receptions and 120 yards. He also beat previously-benched cornerback Melvin White for a fourth-quarter touchdown.
Bengals No. 2 back Jeremy Hill added 22 yards on eight carries.
Brad Nortman punted just once for 38 yards.
Philly Brown gained five yards on his only punt return, and he averaged 22.3 yards on six kickoff returns.
Offensive coordinator Mike Shula called arguably his best game of the season.
Defensive coordinator Sean McDermott, whose unit is nowhere close to the 2013 group that was the second-best defense in the NFL, is going to have another sleepless week with a game against the potent Packers ahead.